Last year, I remodelled my bathroom. There was a time when I hit a wall. No, not literally. But design-wise. I kept scrolling through the Pinterest boards and bathroom remodel ideas. I went through Houzz and other magazines. But I kept on wondering. Should I opt for a sleek walk-in shower or stick with a cosy bathtub?

It was a simple bathroom design choice. However, I later realised that this decision affects many things. Factors such as space, comfort, and resale value. It even impacts how I start and end my day. If you have ever found yourself in this same situation, trying to decide between a walk-in shower and a tub, this guide will help you weigh the pros, cons, and hidden trade-offs that designers often discuss.

Why This Decision Really Matters

The overall look of the bathroom is dictated by the choices you make. It also outlines how you live. A walk-in shower offers an open-concept, modern bathroom design. A bathtub adds relaxation and resale appeal.

According to Baths R Us, curbless walk-in showers are among the top bathroom renovation trends in 2026. They combine style with accessibility.

Another study by Remodel Inspo warns that removing the only tub in a home could lower appeal for family buyers.

So, it is not just about what’s trendy. It is actually about striking the design balance.

Pros And Cons Of A Walk-In Shower

Advantages Of a Walk-In Shower

•                 Space efficiency & modern look:

A walk-in shower often opens up the floor plan, making the bathroom feel larger and cleaner.

•                 Accessibility & practicality:

It is beneficial to think ahead when you have low thresholds, as there is no need to step over tub walls, and it's easier for ageing in place.

•                 Daily-use convenience:

If your household showers more than baths, this design aligns with how you really live.

•                 Design forward:

Trends indicate that walk-in showers with frameless glass, large tile, and minimal hardware are expected to dominate design choices in 2026.

Drawbacks Of Having a Walk-In Shower

1.               You may lose the bath-soaking experience that a tub offers.
2.               Premium walk-in showers (especially custom ones) can cost more than a basic tub installation.
3.               If your home ends up without a tub at all, it may limit its appeal to families in specific resale markets.

A Walk-In Shower Is Suitable For

A walk-in shower makes most sense if you:

•                 Have a smaller bathroom and want it to feel open.
•                 Shower daily and avoid soaking rarely (or never).
•                 Prioritise accessibility for the future, or opt for a sleek, modern aesthetic.
•                 Are you okay with passing on a tub experience in favour of efficiency and style?

Pros And Cons Of Having a Bathtub In Your Bathroom

Advantages Of Bath Tubs

•                 Soaking & relaxation:

A tub invites a whole bath experience. There is muscle relaxation, quiet time, and even a spa-like retreat.

•                 Family friendly:

They are ideal when you have kids, pets, or want multi-use functionality (such as bath time or washing large items).

•                 Resale and expectation:

For many buyers, having at least one tub in the home remains a comfort factor.

Drawbacks Of Bath Tubs In Bathrooms

1.               Takes up more floor space. Possibly crowding vanities or limiting layout options.
2.               Less convenient for daily use if most of the household showers are.
3.               Step over tub walls can become less ideal as you age or for someone with mobility issues.
4.               If you rarely use the tub, the footprint may feel like wasted space in a lean layout.

Bath Tubs Are Most Suitable When

A tub makes the most sense if you:

•                 Plan to stay in your home for many years and value baths.
•                 Have children or regularly use the tub for multiple purposes.
•                 Have a larger bathroom that can accommodate the footprint without sacrificing flow.
•                 Want to maintain a “luxury bath” appeal and don’t mind the extra space/maintenance.

How Modern Designers Mix The Two

In 2026, bathroom designers are combining walk-in showers and soaking tubs to offer the best of both worlds. This involves creating freestanding tubs adjacent to a glass-enclosed shower area. This bathroom design is open, airy, and functional.

Designers predict dual-zone bathrooms are trending. This is especially true for the master suites. It is all about striking a balance between efficiency and indulgence. Having the shower for everyday use and the tub for special self-care moments.

Which One Is Better For Your Home

Consider these factors to determine which option, a walk-in shower or a bathtub, makes the most sense for your home.

Consider Your Space

Small bathroom? A walk-in shower helps it feel bigger. Got extra square footage? A tub makes a visual statement.

Think About Lifestyle

If you're showering daily and never soaking, why waste the space? If you love unwinding in a warm bath or have kids, tubs are the winner.

Look Ahead To Resale

For long-term homes, go for what you love. For short-term investment properties, a combo setup appeals to more buyers.

Weigh The Cost And Upkeep

A basic tub installation typically starts at around $1,200–$3,000, while a quality walk-in shower remodel averages $4,000–$8,000, depending on the materials and any necessary plumbing changes.

The Verdict: Find What Fits You

The walk-in shower vs tub argument is all about designing your bathroom with your preferences.

Consider a walk-in shower if you prefer a sleek design, easy cleaning, and daily convenience. But if you love soaking in water, then go for the tub. It is best if you have a family or want timeless comfort.

And if space and budget are enough, you should definitely have both. This will create a truly versatile and modern bathroom remodel.